Wait, didnt I already review the 2010s? Indeed I did! See here for my picks for the best albums of the 2010s from that first review. But we’re not quite done, and the reason why involves 2024…It turns out that 2024 is the 25th year of the millennium. And that is just too rich a symbolic target for me to forgo- the chance to review the best albums of the past 25 years! I have all the source material I’ll need: I’ve reviewed the 2000s in several venues, did the above-mentioned 2010s review, and have top 20-23 lists for 2020, 2021, 2022 & 2023, with the search for 24 for 2024 now underway.
But my 2010s list is a little light comparatively. While my 2000s list from various sources sports around 60 entries, my 2010s review of 52 of the the critic’s top-ranked albums resulted in 34 picks. In order to balance that out a bit decade by decade, I’ve decided to go ahead and review the next tier down of 2010s albums per my original source lists. That will give us 36 more albums to review, which I’ll do in 6 blocks of 6. And hopefully thereby have a few more picks for our Grand Review of 2000-2024 to come!
Got it? Okay, let’s go with part 2!
Coloring Book (Chance the Rapper, 2016)– Acid Rap was one of my favorites of the v1 2010s review, so I definitely came in to this album interested. And it does share exuberant sonic landscapes and a winning personality with that earlier album. In fact, the best tracks here are really great, easily up to decade’s best status. But as a whole it doesn’t quite feel coherent sonically, thematically, or in terms of flow. Not for the first time, a collection of great songs does not necessarily a successful album make!
Pop2 (Charli XCX, 2017)– Similar to the above entry, Charli XCX was already on my radar for her album how i’m feeling now having been one of my top 20 picks for 2020. This outing is also tickling my fancy. It is, to be sure, very highly produced and sometimes autotuned EDM. But it has a sharp jagged energy to it, keeps moving, and pulls out many sonic surprises along the way. Dance music isn’t going anywhere. Dance music shouldn’t go anywhere. So may it be this good!
Settle (Disclosure, 2013)– I am told that Disclosure is an English electronic music duo. This seems plausible, and I find no reason to doubt it. Indeed, a quick listen here bears that out, and it the album down a good background groove. I especially appreciate the more than occasional dips into classic 303 synth bass territory. But I don’t really feel like this adds up to more than a sum of parts.
If You’re Reading This It’s Too Late (Drake, 2015)– You know, it is really nice to see a mix tape succeed! His 2011 album Take Care made my original 2010s list, but it did strike me as a little too slick. This is much rawer, with at times even an air of desperation, without sacrificing quality. Some of that’s inherent to mixtape as a form, but maybe also having hit it really big with the earlier album, he had some ambivalent feelings to process (there’s lyrical evidence for this), or just had the confidence and comfort to release something with less trimming and grooming? Wherever it comes from, with a little more than an hour run time there isn’t a single track I tuned out on.
I Love You, Honeybear (Father John Misty, 2015)– I’ve certainly heard of Father John, and seen him play on a late night show here and there, but wouldn’t have considered myself super-familiar. That being said, this kind of thing is right up my alley- a country-inflected southern California folk with reference to some classic R&B sounds and a lush production level on top that raises everything to theatrical levels. The shimmery beauty is perfectly offset by the frequently highly bitter and cutting lyrics, and a heartfelt voice that feels totally sincere in celebrating the beauty and the pain. I think we’ve got a winner!
World War 3 (Gas) (Gucci Mane, 2015)– There’s definitely some skill and welcome flow to this hip-hop album, and some welcome disruptive tongue in check energy. It’s also very autotuned, cliche bound, and kind of sing-songy and same after a while. In a decade with so much hip hop wealth, I just don’t see this as being a decade’s best.
So there we are with the batch two of six of the 36 overflow albums for the 2010s that I’ll be reviewing! From this batch, I would say If You’re Reading This It’s Too Late and I Love You Honeybear are definite “yeses”, and Pop2 is a “maybe”. Who knows what may await us in albums 13-18?
Okay, lets start off with the obvious question- why am I revisiting the 2010s again? Didn’t I already do that? Indeed I did! See here for my picks for the best albums of the 2010s from that first review. But we’re not quite done, and the reason why involves 2024…
It turns out that 2024 is the 25th year of the millennium. And that is just too rich a symbolic target for me to forgo- the chance to review the best albums of the past 25 years! I have all the source material I’ll need: I’ve reviewed the 2000s in several venues, did the above-mentioned 2010s review, and have top 20-23 lists for 2020, 2021, 2022 & 2023, with the search for 24 for 2024 now underway.
But my 2010s list is a little light comparatively. While my 2000s list from various sources sports around 60 entries, my 2010s review of 52 of the the critic’s top-ranked albums resulted in 34 picks. In order to balance that out a bit decade by decade, I’ve decided to go ahead and review the next tier down of 2010s albums per my original source lists. That will give us 36 more albums to review, which I’ll do in 6 blocks of 6. And hopefully thereby have a few more picks for our Grand Review of 2000-2024 to come!
Got it? Okay, let’s go!
21 (Adele, 2011)– I really can’t comprehend how this didn’t rank higher in the critical consensus and end up in the first batch of 52 albums I reviewed. Is there a better album start out there in the decade than the one-two punch of the bombastic churn of “Rolling in the Deep” and the stomping beat and savage ending of “Rumor Has It”? And that’s just tenderizer before you eventually get emotionally ransacked by “Set Fire to the Rain” and “Someone Like You”. I don’t know about you, but every one of those songs still lives in my soul now a dozen years later. And, between the depth and yearning tenderness of her voice, rich blue-eyed soul instrumentation, and lyrical emotional complexity, even the “filler” here is gorgeous. If this isn’t a best of that decade, I don’t know what is.
Malibu (Anderson .Paak, 2016)– His 2021 collaboration with Bruno Mars, Silk Sonic, made my honorable mention for that year, so I’m coming in to this well-disposed. This has many of the the same charms of that outing, namely Paak’s masterful mix of neo-soul, hip-hop, and club music, smooth vocals, interesting sample choices, and witty and complex lyrics. The best songs here are flat out great, but it doesn’t sound or feel totally together, which you need to make an hour+ album work. Still, there isn’t a track along the way that I was unhappy to be there for.
X 100PRE (Bad Bunny, 2018)– I am told I should like Bad Bunny, and so I tried with his album YHLQMDLG (which I was assured I should like) for my 2020 review. And it’s not like I’m mad at him, but… I’ll give it that his music on this album has personality, and some interesting mix and vocal moments. There are some singles I quite like. But a lot of it is very much the autotuned 21st century hip-hop sound that leaves me cold. And at nearly an hour, I need it to be compelling the whole way through to work as an album.
Cupid Deluxe (Blood Orange, 2013)– I am told that Dev Hynes, aka Blood Orange, is an American-born English singer, songwriter, and record producer based in New York City, who has worked extensively writing and producing for others in addition to his own work. That sounds promising enough, but the opening track is some kind of autotuned low-key soul mush. It does pick up and get more lively and funky on the second track, thank goodness. And from there goes on to pleasantly explore several modes of contemporary soul/R&B, with occasional dips back into mushy tracks. It’s often quite good, but given the uneveness, I don’t see it as “decade’s best” material.
22, A Million (Bon Iver, 2016)– This album has an interesting, somewhat dizzying start, bridging the gulf between an acoustical indie and electric kazoo chipmunk sound before drifting off into jazz. The second track has a kind of 70s AM radio feel delivered via glitchy electronic. I could go on narrating track by track, but the point is that there’s a surprising and varied experimentalism that stays just enough in touch with pop song conventions to make the songs work. By its very nature all this comes off as a bit disjointed, and is abstract, but it was headed toward at least a strong “maybe” until it had too many songs in a row that were too lulled out in the second half.
Teens of Denial (Car Seat Headrest, 2016)– My initial take is that this feels like an album that was a few years late for the 2001-2006 heyday of the garage rock revival scene. Subsequent research reveals that the Seattle-based, Virginia-derived band behind it got going in 2010, so it makes sense as the kind of second wave of that scene. This is also apparently their tenth album in a 7-year period, and as witness to that, it’s a tight and confident sound that’s on display here. All of that is just a blah-blah-blah though, and the real story is music that never lets up, and smart lyrics on varied topics. I’m a little leery of the length- you have to work hard to pull off a 70-minute run time, but that’s my only source of hesitation here.
So there we are with the first 6 of the 36 overflow albums for the 2010s that I’ll be reviewing. From this batch, I would say 21 is a definite “yes”, and Malibu and Teens of Denial are “maybes”. Let’s see what we find in albums 7-12!
If you’re just joining us for the first time, and are wondering what the heck is going on here, in 2021 I set out to catch up on newer music, which I hadn’t really done in about a decade at that point for various reasons.
I listened to the critics choices for the best albums of the 2010s, and picked my own favorites. I did the same for 2020, picking my top 20 from the critics most highly rated albums. And I started off listening to new releases each month in 2021, eventually picking the 21 best albums of 2021. I had so much fun in the process that I decided to do it again in 2022 and 2023, listening each month and picking out the 22 best albums of 2022 and the 23 best albums of 2023.
There are links to the albums in the posts, but if you’d like a one-stop playlist, I’ve got that set up in Spotify for the 2021 top 21 and the 2022 top 22, and in YouTube Music for 23 Best Albums of 2023. (Eventually I’ll move the 2021 and 2022 lists to YouTube, because artists are asking us to avoid Spotify for very good reasons.)
Okay, so now you know what we’re doing. Well guess what? I’m doing it again! A quick word on the “yes” and “maybe” categories I’ve sorted things into, and then we’ll get going:
Yes– This isn’t a guarantee, but it represents the albums that, upon first listen, I think could definitely be in running for best of the year.
Maybe– These albums have something to recommend them, but also something that gives me pause. I’m putting them in their own category, because I have found “maybes” sometimes linger and eventually become “yeses”.
And now, without any further ado, let us get on with my top picks from 71 new January releases that I listened to!
21 Savage, American Dream– Dreamlike classic grooves backing glitchy beats, philosophical lyrics, and presented with a steady accessible flow. It may run with cliché themes at times, but it also never let me down for the entire 50-minute run. In the hands of this British-American artist, hip hop is not dead!
Billy Porter, Black Mona Lisa– Clear, powerful, and masterful in its feeling for the dance, R&B, and Broadway idioms it targets. That, frankly, might be enough even if it had no particular import on top of it, but in this era of bubbling danger against people of diverse races and sexualities in America, actor and singer Billy Porter leaves no punches pulled. Without sacrificing the sheer joy of the music in the process!
Charley Crockett, $10 Cowboy– I knew from the title that I was potentially in danger of love, and indeed. Suffused with a feeling for both outlaw country and the Nashville sound (and the seventies intersection of R&B & country), and songs here are musically straight up while channeling being down and out in America. As solid a set of songs as you could ask for to remind you that country can still country and thank God for that!
Cheekface, It’s Sorted– Goony new wave music! Goony new wave vocals! Goony new wave lyrics! I could have heard this on college radio in the eighties and I would have loved it. But the lyrics are about things like changes in the New England hardcore scene, drones not leaving you alone, and dark web e-mail breaches, so plenty current. There is an artlessness here that’s pure fun, and a sound that is seriously sharp at the same time as it’s being silly. Per the Wikipedia article on this Southern California band, they’ve been compared to Stephen Malkmus, LCD Soundsystem, The Dismemberment Plan, Jeff Rosenstock, The B-52’s, and Devo. Okay, plucky little band. Okay!
Eye Flys, Eye Flys– This is giving me some serious Melvins and Mastodon vibes, which if you know, tells you a lot. But if you don’t know- it is Heavy! And lumbering and sludgy, pulling you under in the best kind of way. I haven’t been this enamored of a new metallic release in a while.
Kula Shaker, Natural Magick– In this case, the cover gives you a highly accurate clue! This album has a nice rollicking sixties garage rock sound, with layers of psychedelia and Indian pop influences. It’s almost hard to believe at times that this isn’t a genuine artifact from circa 1968-1972, and also hard to find anything to not like about it. Kula Shaker made my honorable mention list for 2022, and I have a feeling they are going to be in contention again this year.
Neil Young & Crazy Horse, FU##IN’ UP– Oh, I like this one! This is the lyrically and sonically dense and seething Crazy Horse that I personally can never get enough of. Per another review: “Neil Young’s latest effort with his longtime backing back Crazy Horse is both a new album and an old one. FU##IN’ UP is a spiritual sibling to their 1990 comeback album Ragged Glory, but this time repurposing each track with loose, sprawling, guttural new edges.” Even as a derivation, I can’t fault it!
SPLLIT, Infinite Hatch– I love the perfect lo-fi pop-rock as mutated by off-kilter rhythms, electronic squelches, and weird and snarky lyrics. This is a good example of how being “damn fun” renders “not necessarily profound” utterly irrelevant as an objection. Get going little Baton Rouge band!
Tapir!, The Pilgrim, Their God and the King of My Decrepit Mountain– Are you in the market for some beautiful, oddly anguished folky pop? I am told that, “Tapir! is a six-piece indie folk band from London. Known for their blending of folk music with genres such as post-punk and art pop.” I’ll tell you that I found this to be intriguing from start to finish!
Trevor Horn, Echoes: Ancient & Modern– The “ancient” echoes here are perhaps twofold, Horn himself, a widely influential music producer in the 80s (and founding member of The Buggles’ and power behind their single “Video Killed the Radio Star”), and the song cover choices, hearkening back to his 80s heyday. If so, the “modern” ones are surely the polished reworkings and the new power the songs draw from his touch and his smartly curated list of guest stars. I recommend this for fans of both the eighties, and fans of albums where you can see a producer show off doing their thing.
Maybe
Angry Blackmen, The Legend of ABM– Sharp cutting sounds, inventive stuttering glitchy mix, lyrics with weight. The vocals are a little flat, but the mix is magic, and the best songs are revelatory.
Bruiser Wolf, My Story Got Stories– One of my favorites of 2021 for his album Dope Game Stupid is doing it again! The hilarious verbal barrage, tongue in cheek delivery, repositioning of hip hop history and presenting himself as an OG who ought to shuffle off the stage while simultaneously not ceding an inch of it is a winning combo. Maybe not quite as sharp as his 2021 outing, but still with plenty to recommend it.
Ekko Astral, pink balloons– Fuzzy, distorted, properly serrated, with dense elliptical lyrics that perhaps involve anonymous burials, sexism, and never having seen Star Wars? If not totally together, it is an echo, astral in a noisy way, and thank goodness for it.
Loukeman, Sd-2– What I read that got me interested was “The Canadian producer laces glow-worm synths and house beats with vocal snippets culled from indie-folk gems and Billboard hits.” And indeed, it does sound like that, and very unlike other electronic projects floating out there. It sometimes drifted a little toward the abstract, which was my hesitation, but I also never wanted to turn it off. Three cheers for folks who are still out there looking for new soundscapes!
Marika Hackman, Big Sigh– Nuanced and textured, with an acoustic style but instrument surges reminiscent of the nineties. The deep, emotionally literate lyrics that cut in both directions are appreciated. It is a little one tone- musically and vocally, but powerful.
Nicholas Craven/Boldy James, Penalty of Leadership– Dense, cinematic mix and lyrics, and rich seventies soul-feeling backing. The flow is a little flat, but that fits the darkly textured picture being painted.
Pearl Jam, Dark Matter– We can perhaps agree there’s not going to be a “bad” Pearl Jam album. The lads just don’t have it in them! But this is not “merely” a “not bad” Pearl Jam album, it has quite a bit of verve and snap to it, and if it’s not the freshest thing ever, it is my favorite album of theirs since the eponymous 2006 album. There’s more than a bit here (without sounding AT ALL old and fogey) of the feeling of the wise and world-weary checking in that you would hope for from your veteran acts. For anyone who objects to that characterization, keep in mind that there is archival evidence that Pearl Jam’s first album came out 33 years ago, and that other albums that likewise came out 33 years ago during their 1991 debut were released in 1958. I object!
Sleater-Kinney, Little Rope– A nuanced album which rocks plenty hard, but also has textured depths. If it is not totally focused, and it isn’t as thunderous as my best-loved albums from them, it is about something, and has depths that repay attention without losing sonic verve.
St. Vincent, All Born Screaming– As darkling as any of her earlier work, but with variety, verve, and wit as well. I like it best when it’s waxing a little less meditative and a little groovier, but she does self-bill it as a “post-plague” album, so I cannot begrudge her the tone. Definitely worth another listen!
Ty Segal, Three Bells– I mean, you get me your fuzzed out nineties garage rock, pepper it with heavy trip 70s psych rock vibes, put it in the hands of a past master in these forms… About my only hesitation is the hour+ run time vis-à-vis how heavy it gets in parts. But regardless, rock on!
And there we have January, out in the first third of May! Let’s see what we can do with February!
I mean, given, the century is only about 1/4 done. It’s our biggest rematch so far though! Also, apologies for not picking this up again since early primary season. There have been health issues, but now that the General Election is only 6 months out, I’ve decided it’s time to start getting more regular with it.
Six months out is a long time politically, especially given some factors I’ll mention later, but it’s also not an infinite amount of time, and there are multiple indicators we can look at to see what the current outlook is. The first would be national polls, and on this both the Real Clear Politics average, which is kind of a straightforward averaging of various recent polls, and the 538 average, which weights things according to pollster track record and history of partisan lean, are telling the same story:
It should be noted that this result is well within a standard 3% or so margin of error, so it’s hardly a decisive reading. What do polls of the swing states most likely to decide the election tell us? Here again RCP and 538 tell the same story, showing Trump leading in 7 of 7. Here are the current 538 numbers by state:
Again, proper caution regarding three of these results being within a standard margin of error. On the electoral college front, as you might suspect from the swing state results, the current map has Trump comfortably ahead:
Another indicator we might look at is Presidential Approval ratings. On this front too there’s plenty of evidence of trouble for Biden. He’s currently more than 17 points underwater (this average is from 538):
Crucially, he’s also lower in net approval than the four most recent Presidents defeated after their first term (Ford, Carter, H.W. Bush, and Trump):
Not all indicators are pointing in this direction though. The Generic Congressional ballot shows a preference for the Democrats, albeit a rather narrow one:
And Democrats have also consistently outperformed in special elections year to date, running an average of 5% ahead of the partisan lean of the races in question (per a spreadsheet compiled by Nathaniel Rakich of 538):
Both of these factors indicate that it’s actually a pro-Democratic electorate out there, and there’s also another thing to consider- Biden’s percentage in Democratic primaries is well ahead, in total of Trump’s in Republican primaries:
This suggests, other factors being equal, that Trump still has a lot more of the faithful to bring home than Biden does. And given that the 2106 election came down to 78,000 votes in Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, and the 2020 election came down to 42,000 votes in Georgia, Arizona, and Wisconsin, even a small marginal difference in enthusiasm of core voters could be decisive.
There’s one last area we can look at, which is what the Presidential betting markets are currently showing. Kind of a wonky indicator, but it is data of another sort, and crucially, a forecast people are laying real dollars on the table for. Here it’s a narrow Trump advantage at the moment:
So what do I think?
There are some good reasons to be cautious about the whole data picture at the moment. National polls are showing Kennedy with up to 10%, and state polls are showing up to 20% undecided. Frankly, these aren’t credible results, in the sense that they aren’t voters saying they have no idea what they are doing, or definitely voting against Biden and Trump. They’re voters who do have a leaning, but haven’t yet made peace with where they’re eventually going to end up. In other words, these votes are going somewhere, we just don’t know where yet.
There’s also how far out we are. To give one example of a news item that we know is coming, Trump could be a convicted felon by the time I do another update. That won’t shake the faithful, but it may certainly move some voters at the margins. And in general there are the conventions, the Republican VP pick, the effect of debates if they end up happening, and who knows how many unexpected news items between now and then.
There’s no question that if the election were held today, Trump would be a better than even favorite to win. But it’s not being held today, and for all the reasons cited above, these numbers are going to be a lot more meaningful at three, two or one month out than they are now.
So, for now what we have is the factors as they’re currently aligned, which will give us a good basis for spotting changes over time:
That’s where we are for now, and I’ll aim to do another update circa June 5th, at which point we’ll be five months out. See you then!
Chris LaMay-West 